Hear from Our Customers
You check your oil gauge less. You sleep better during cold snaps. You stop worrying about whether your delivery will actually show up when you need it most.
That’s what happens when you work with a heating oil company that’s been serving Suffolk County for over 50 years. We understand that living on Fishers Island means you can’t just run to the corner store when your tank runs low. You need a supplier who takes your heating seriously and delivers exactly when promised.
Our customers tell us the same thing: they finally found a heating oil company they can count on. No games, no surprises, just reliable service that keeps their homes warm all season long. When Fishers Island temperatures drop as low as 42.5°F each winter, you need heating oil that arrives on time, every time.
We’ve been delivering heating oil throughout Suffolk County for over five decades. We’re not the biggest company, but we’re the most reliable.
We started serving Suffolk County homeowners because we saw too many families getting burned by companies that promised the world and delivered headaches. Hidden fees, missed deliveries, and surprise charges were the norm – some companies wanted over $900 just to locate a tank. We decided to do things differently.
Today, we serve thousands of homes across Suffolk County, including remote areas like Fishers Island. With only 8 heating oil companies serving Fishers Island and 5,782 gallons delivered during winter 2024, our drivers know the roads, understand the challenges, and treat every delivery like it’s going to their own family.
First, you place your order through our 24/7 online system or give us a call. You’ll see the current price per gallon upfront – no guessing, no surprises. Choose how much oil you need, from 25 gallons to a full tank, and select your payment method.
Next, we process your order immediately and schedule your delivery within 1-2 business days. Our experienced drivers load up with high-quality #2 heating oil and head your way. They know Suffolk County like the back of their hand, including the unique challenges of getting to Fishers Island.
Finally, we deliver your oil safely and efficiently. If you’re paying by credit card, you don’t even need to be home. Our drivers handle everything professionally and clean up after themselves. You get a full tank and peace of mind, knowing your next delivery is just a phone call or click away.
Ready to get started?
Every delivery includes premium #2 heating oil that burns clean and efficiently in your system. We’re fully licensed by New York State and completely insured, so you’re protected every step of the way.
You get transparent pricing with no hidden fees or surprise charges. We can offer the best prices in Suffolk County because we never charge for repairs, finance fees, or anything else you might not be aware of. Our online ordering system works 24/7, 365 days a year, so you can place orders whenever it’s convenient for you.
Living on Fishers Island means dealing with unique logistics that mainland suppliers sometimes don’t understand. With heating oil used by 60% of Fishers Island homes, despite a 78% drop since 2017, we’ve been serving Suffolk County’s remote areas for decades. We know how to get oil to your home safely and on time, regardless of weather or road conditions. That’s the kind of local knowledge you can’t get from a national chain.
We typically deliver heating oil to Fishers Island within 1-2 business days of your order. Our drivers are familiar with the island and plan their routes to ensure reliable delivery even during challenging weather conditions.
Since Fishers Island requires special logistics compared to mainland Suffolk County deliveries, we coordinate our island deliveries to maximize efficiency. This means your oil gets delivered promptly without the premium pricing some companies charge for remote locations.
If you’re running critically low, give us a call when you place your online order. We’ll do everything possible to prioritize your delivery and keep your home warm.
Our heating oil prices are displayed in real-time on our online ordering system, so you always see current market pricing before you buy. We update our prices regularly to reflect market conditions and never add hidden fees or surprise charges.
Unlike some heating oil companies that charge extra for island deliveries, our pricing is straightforward and fair. You pay the posted price per gallon, plus applicable taxes – that’s it. No delivery fees, no service charges, no “fuel surcharges” that mysteriously appear on your bill.
We’ve found that transparent pricing builds trust with our customers. When you know exactly what you’re paying upfront, you can budget accordingly and avoid the sticker shock that comes with some other suppliers.
If you’re paying by credit card, you don’t need to be home for delivery. Our experienced drivers will locate your oil fill pipe, complete the delivery safely, and leave everything clean and secure.
For cash payments, someone needs to be available by 7 AM on delivery day with the full payment amount. We understand this can be inconvenient, which is why many of our customers prefer the credit card option for its flexibility.
Our drivers are trained professionals who’ve been making deliveries throughout Suffolk County for years. They know how to access your tank safely and will take care of your property like it’s their own. You can trust them to handle your delivery properly whether you’re home or not.
Most homes on Fishers Island have 275-gallon oil tanks, which is the standard size throughout Suffolk County. If your tank is about 1/4 full, we typically recommend ordering 150 gallons to take advantage of bulk pricing while leaving room for thermal expansion.
During peak winter months when temperatures drop to the 40s, an average Fishers Island home uses about 2 gallons per day for heating. This means a full 275-gallon tank should last roughly 4-5 months, depending on your home’s size, insulation, and thermostat settings.
Our online ordering system lets you choose anywhere from 25 gallons to 5,000 gallons, or simply click “fill my tank” if you want us to top you off completely. When in doubt, it’s better to order more during the summer months when prices are typically lower than waiting until the peak heating season.
We deliver the same high-quality #2 heating oil that meets all New York State specifications for home heating. The difference isn’t in the product – it’s in how we do business and serve our customers.
We’ve been serving Suffolk County for over 50 years, which means we understand the unique challenges of delivering to places like Fishers Island. Our drivers know the roads, the logistics, and how to get your oil delivered reliably regardless of conditions.
What really sets us apart is our no-nonsense approach to pricing and service. We don’t charge hidden fees, we don’t play games with pricing, and we don’t make promises we can’t keep. You get fair prices, reliable delivery, and straightforward service from a company that’s been part of the Suffolk County community for decades.
We focus on will-call service, which means you place orders when you need oil rather than us trying to guess when you’ll run low. This approach actually works better for most Fishers Island residents because your heating needs can vary significantly based on weather, occupancy, and seasonal patterns.
Our 24/7 online ordering system makes it easy to place orders whenever it’s convenient for you. Many customers check their tank monthly and place orders when they hit the 1/4 tank mark, which ensures they never run out while getting the best value.
This system gives you complete control over your heating oil purchases. You can time your orders to take advantage of seasonal price fluctuations, since summer months offer the lowest prices while September through April represents peak demand, or adjust your delivery schedule based on your actual usage patterns rather than someone else’s estimate.
Local Resources
Useful Links
Other Services we provide in Fishers Island
