Hear from Our Customers
You wake up to a warm house every morning, even during the coldest Long Island winters. Your heating system runs smoothly because you’re getting quality #2 heating oil delivered on time, every time.
No more checking your tank gauge every week or worrying about whether you’ll have enough fuel to get through the next cold snap. No more emergency calls to find someone who can deliver oil on a Sunday night when temperatures drop.
Your heating bills become predictable because you’re working with a company that’s been doing this for over 70 years—one that knows how to keep Suffolk County homes warm without the runaround.
We’ve been keeping Long Island homes warm for over seven decades. We’re not the new guys trying to figure things out—we’re the company your neighbors have relied on through countless winters.
We’re fully licensed by New York State and completely insured, which matters when someone’s delivering fuel to your property. What really sets us apart is our no-frills approach: quality heating oil, fair pricing, and none of the hidden fees that other companies sneak into your bill.
In Setauket, where over half the homes depend on heating oil, you need a supplier who understands Long Island winters and won’t leave you hanging when demand spikes.
You can order online 24/7 at suffolkoil.com or call us directly. Choose anywhere from 25 gallons to 5,000 gallons, or just click “fill my tank” and we’ll handle the rest. You’ll see the current price per gallon upfront—no guessing games.
Once you place your order, we process it immediately and schedule delivery within 1-2 business days. Our licensed drivers deliver quality #2 heating oil directly to your tank, and you pay either by credit card or cash on delivery.
That’s it. No contracts, no monthly fees, no surprise charges. Just reliable heating oil delivery when you need it, at a price you can see before you buy.
Ready to get started?
Every gallon of heating oil we deliver meets strict quality standards for clean, efficient burning. You’re getting the same grade of fuel that’s kept Long Island homes comfortable for decades, delivered by drivers who know the area and understand the importance of reliable service.
In Setauket, where winter temperatures regularly drop into the 30s and heating oil demand can spike overnight, timing matters. We maintain the inventory and delivery capacity to serve you even during peak demand periods when other companies might be scrambling.
Our Suffolk County location means shorter delivery routes and faster response times for Setauket residents. Whether you’re dealing with an unexpected cold snap or just need your regular winter supply, we’re positioned to serve the North Shore efficiently and reliably.
Heating oil prices in Setauket fluctuate based on market conditions, typically ranging from $3.00 to $4.50 per gallon depending on the season and crude oil prices. We display current pricing on our website before you order, so you always know exactly what you’re paying.
Summer months (May through September) generally offer the lowest prices due to reduced demand. Winter prices tend to be higher, especially during peak heating season from December through February. The best way to manage costs is to fill up during warmer months when possible and work with a supplier who offers transparent, no-hidden-fee pricing like we do.
We typically deliver within 1-2 business days of your order. Since we’re located right here in Suffolk County, Setauket deliveries are part of our regular route, which means faster service than companies based farther away.
During peak winter months, we recommend ordering when your tank is around 1/4 full rather than waiting until you’re nearly empty. This gives you a buffer in case weather conditions cause delays. Our online ordering system is available 24/7, so you can place orders even on weekends, and we’ll process them first thing Monday morning.
While we don’t advertise 24/7 emergency service, we understand that heating emergencies happen, especially during Long Island’s unpredictable winter weather. If you’re truly out of oil and facing a heating emergency, call us at 631-924-4030 and we’ll do everything possible to help.
The best approach is preventive: order oil when your tank is about 1/4 full, and consider filling up before major storms are predicted. This way, you avoid emergency situations altogether. Many Setauket residents find that checking their tank monthly during heating season helps them stay ahead of their fuel needs.
We accept both credit card payments and cash on delivery (COD). You can choose your payment method when placing your order online or over the phone. Credit card payments are processed securely, and COD payments are handled directly with our delivery driver.
Many customers prefer COD because it allows them to pay current market rates without locking into contracts or prepayment plans. Others like the convenience of credit card payments for record-keeping purposes. Either way, you’ll see the total cost before delivery, with no hidden fees or surprise charges added to your bill.
Most Setauket homes have either 275-gallon or 330-gallon tanks. You can check your tank gauge to see current levels, or use our “fill my tank” option and we’ll deliver exactly what you need to fill it up. If you’re unsure about your tank size, it’s usually marked on the tank itself or in your home’s documentation.
A good rule of thumb for Long Island homes: a typical 2,000 square foot house uses about 800-1,200 gallons per heating season, depending on insulation, thermostat settings, and winter severity. During peak winter months, you might use 150-200 gallons per month, while shoulder seasons require much less.
No. The price you see is the price you pay—no delivery fees, no fuel surcharges, no environmental fees, and no surprise add-ons. This is part of our no-frills approach that’s kept Suffolk County customers happy for over 70 years.
Some heating oil companies add various fees that can increase your total cost by $0.50 or more per gallon. We believe in transparent pricing: you see the per-gallon cost, multiply by the gallons delivered, and that’s your total. It’s straightforward pricing that lets you budget accurately and compare costs honestly with other suppliers.
Local Resources
Useful Links
Other Services we provide in Setauket
