Hear from Our Customers
Your heating oil tank stays full without you thinking about it. No more middle-of-the-night panic when temperatures drop to 25°F and your heat stops working.
You get quality fuel delivered on schedule, competitive pricing without surprises, and the confidence that comes from working with a company that’s been serving Suffolk County families for over five decades. Our online ordering system makes managing your heating oil as simple as a few clicks.
When Shelter Island’s winter weather hits hard, you’re covered. Your family stays warm, your budget stays predictable, and your heating system gets the clean-burning fuel it needs to run efficiently all season long.
We’ve been delivering heating oil to Suffolk County homes since the 1970s. We understand what it takes to keep island families comfortable through Long Island’s unpredictable winters.
While other companies treat Shelter Island as just another stop on their route, we know the unique challenges of island deliveries. We’ve built our reputation by showing up when we say we will, charging fair prices, and treating every customer like a neighbor.
Our drivers know the roads, understand the weather patterns, and respect the fact that running out of heating oil on Shelter Island isn’t just inconvenient—it can be dangerous when temperatures drop and ferry schedules get disrupted by winter storms.
Order online or give us a call with how many gallons you need. Our system shows you the current price per gallon upfront—no games, no surprises. Most customers find our 150-gallon minimum order hits the sweet spot for bulk pricing while keeping their tanks properly filled.
We schedule your delivery based on your preference and our route efficiency. Our experienced drivers handle the entire delivery process, including checking your tank, filling it safely, and leaving you a detailed delivery ticket. You don’t need to be home for most deliveries.
Payment is straightforward. We accept cash, check, or credit card, and you have 30 days to pay your invoice. Many customers set up automatic delivery schedules so their tanks get refilled before they run low, especially during the peak heating months when demand is highest and weather can be unpredictable.
Ready to get started?
You get clean-burning #2 heating oil that’s additized for better performance and longer equipment life. Our fuel meets all New York State requirements and burns efficiently in standard residential heating systems.
Shelter Island’s unique location means timing matters more than on the mainland. We track weather patterns and ferry schedules to ensure deliveries happen when promised. Our local knowledge helps us navigate island logistics that trip up larger, less experienced companies.
We offer flexible delivery options including will-call service for customers who prefer to manage their own schedules, and automatic delivery for those who want the convenience of never having to check their tank levels. Emergency delivery is available for those unexpected situations when you’re running lower than expected during a cold snap.
Heating oil prices in Shelter Island currently range from around $3.49 to $3.50 per gallon for standard residential deliveries. The exact price depends on your order size, payment method, and current market conditions.
We’ve seen prices fluctuate significantly over the past year, reaching as high as $5.66 per gallon during peak demand periods. That’s why we focus on transparent, fair pricing without hidden fees or surprise charges. When you call or order online, you’ll see the current price upfront so you can make an informed decision about when and how much to order.
Yes, we deliver heating oil to Shelter Island year-round, including during winter weather conditions. We understand that heating oil deliveries become even more critical when temperatures drop and ferry schedules can be affected by storms.
Our drivers are experienced with island deliveries and winter driving conditions. We monitor weather forecasts and ferry schedules to plan deliveries accordingly. If severe weather temporarily prevents deliveries, we’ll communicate with you about rescheduling and work to get your delivery completed as soon as conditions allow. Emergency deliveries may be available depending on the specific situation and weather conditions.
Most Shelter Island homeowners with standard 275-gallon tanks order heating oil 3-4 times during the heating season, typically ordering 150-200 gallons each time. This keeps your tank from running too low while taking advantage of bulk pricing that usually kicks in around 150 gallons.
During peak winter months when temperatures regularly drop to the 20s, a typical home might use 150-200 gallons per month. In milder months, usage drops significantly. We recommend keeping at least a quarter tank at all times, especially during winter, since unexpected cold snaps or delivery delays due to weather can leave you vulnerable to running out.
With automatic delivery, we monitor your usage patterns and schedule deliveries before you run low, typically when your tank reaches about 25% capacity. You don’t have to check your tank or remember to call—we handle the timing based on your home’s heating patterns and local weather conditions.
Will-call service means you monitor your own tank levels and call us when you need a delivery. This gives you more control over timing and spending, but requires you to stay on top of your fuel levels, especially during cold weather when usage increases. Many customers prefer automatic delivery during winter months for peace of mind, then switch to will-call during warmer periods when usage is more predictable.
Same-day delivery may be available depending on our current schedule, your location on Shelter Island, and weather conditions. We always try to accommodate urgent requests, especially during cold weather when running out of fuel can create serious comfort and safety issues.
For the best chance of same-day service, call us early in the day before our drivers begin their routes. Keep in mind that same-day delivery typically costs more than scheduled deliveries, but it provides peace of mind when you’re running unexpectedly low. We recommend setting up automatic delivery or monitoring your tank levels regularly to avoid emergency situations whenever possible.
We offer several payment options to make heating oil more manageable for Shelter Island families. You can pay by cash, check, or credit card, and we typically give you 30 days to pay your invoice after delivery.
We also run periodic promotions that we advertise on our website, in local papers, and through direct mailers to customers. These can include discounts for larger orders, early-season pricing, or other special offers. Many customers find that ordering larger quantities (150+ gallons) provides better per-gallon pricing than smaller, more frequent orders. We’re always transparent about our current pricing and any available discounts when you call or order online.
Local Resources
Useful Links
Other Services we provide in Shelter Island
