Hear from Our Customers
You’re tired of heating oil companies that nickel and dime you. Save up to $0.90 per gallon compared to full-service contracts while getting the same quality fuel.
We charge you for one thing: home heating oil. You can see our prices clearly on our website, so you always know what to expect. No service fees, no hidden charges, no automatic deliveries you didn’t ask for.
When winter hits Middle Island, you need heat that works and pricing that’s fair. Our quality products keep your home safely heated all year long without the headaches of locked-in contracts or surprise bills.
Consolidated Energy – Suffolk Oil is the leading oil company near Middle Island, NY. We understand what Suffolk County residents deal with every winter—unpredictable weather and heating bills that can spiral out of control.
Middle Island sits right in the heart of Long Island, between Coram and Ridge, with Rocky Point and Yaphank nearby. We know this area because we serve it every day. We’re proud of our reputation as the best oil company in Suffolk County because of our low prices, superior products, and reliable services.
Local families choose us because we keep things straightforward. In Middle Island, NY, we’re known for fast, reliable service and affordable home heating oil prices.
Scheduling an oil delivery can be done in three easy steps: Create an account on our website, order the oil, and schedule the delivery. That’s it.
Check our daily updated prices online—no phone tag, no waiting for callbacks. We have current oil prices displayed prominently on our website’s homepage, with prices updated daily.
Place your order for the amount you need, when you need it. With our COD oil service, you can order oil when you need it, rather than being locked into a delivery schedule. Your oil gets delivered to your Middle Island home on schedule.
You pay on delivery—cash, check, or card. We accept MasterCard, Visa, American Express, Discover credit/debit cards, bank-certified checks, money orders, and cash on delivery. No contracts, no monthly billing, no surprises.
Ready to get started?
Heating oil is highly efficient, extremely safe, super cost-effective, easily accessible, and more environmentally friendly than other home heating sources. We deliver the same high-grade #2 heating oil that full-service companies use.
B5 heating oil contains 5% biodiesel and is required for Downstate New York including Nassau, Suffolk, NYC, and Westchester counties. Every gallon meets New York State requirements and burns clean in your system.
Middle Island residents get reliable delivery throughout Suffolk County. We’re on the road 7 days a week, 365 days a year. If weather conditions prevent delivery, we’ll notify you immediately and reschedule as soon as it’s safe.
Prices tend to be lower during the summer months (June, July, and August) when demand for heating oil is lower. Smart Middle Island homeowners order ahead during warmer months to lock in better rates before winter demand drives prices up.
Our COD customers typically save $0.50 to $0.90 per gallon compared to full-service options. For a typical 150-gallon delivery, that’s $75 to $135 in immediate savings.
Full-service contracts often mean paying around $1 more per gallon to cover potential repair services you may need. With our COD delivery, you only pay for the oil you’re actually getting. COD oil prices are lower because they don’t include the added costs of full-service delivery, such as maintenance, repairs, and emergency services.
The math is simple: if you’re using 600 gallons per heating season, our COD delivery can save you $300 to $540 annually compared to locked-in service contracts.
Our COD oil delivery means you’re not locked into a long-term service contract, so you have the freedom to shop around and save money. With COD delivery, you have the freedom to choose any supplier you want.
With full-service companies, once you sign a contract (usually for one full year), you’re committed. If prices drop or the company isn’t meeting your needs after a few deliveries, you’re stuck. These contracts often come with significant cancellation fees and penalties.
Our COD service gives you control. Dips in the market rate for oil are passed along to consumers, meaning you can order when the rate is at its lowest. You decide when to order, how much to order, and which company to use.
We recommend refilling your tank when it’s down to about one-quarter full. Most Middle Island homes have 275-gallon tanks, so you’d want to reorder when you have around 70 gallons remaining.
On average in New York, 100 gallons would last about 10 to 15 days during the cold season. The frequency depends on your consumption rate, which fluctuates based on weather conditions and your heating system’s efficiency. Usually, a tank might need refilling every month during heating season.
Check your tank gauge regularly, especially when temperatures drop. Consider your average oil consumption rate to estimate how long remaining oil will last. Most homeowners develop a feel for their usage patterns after a season or two.
Current heating oil prices in Long Island range from $2.94 to $3.50 per gallon, with an average of $3.17. As of January 2025, New York residential heating oil was $4.037 per gallon, but we typically offer better rates.
We display our current oil prices prominently on our homepage, with prices updated daily to keep up with constantly changing oil prices. The highest price spikes happen between December and February when more people are ordering heating oil.
Generally, prices tend to be lower during summer months when demand is lower. However, it’s essential to monitor market conditions regularly as prices can fluctuate due to crude oil costs, geopolitical events, and severe weather.
We provide weekend delivery to the Long Island area and are on the road 7 days a week, 365 days a year. We offer 7 days a week home heating oil delivery.
We offer same-day delivery on orders placed before 10 a.m. We also offer emergency heating oil service if you run out and need a last-minute delivery—we’ll do our best to fit you in the same day with 24/7 emergency delivery service.
You don’t need to be home when your delivery arrives. Our drivers can access most outdoor tanks safely and leave delivery tickets with payment details. Weekend service ensures you never have to wait until Monday if you run low on oil during a cold snap.
There’s no difference in quality and absolutely nothing cheap about it—other than the price. You get the same high quality heating oil you would from a full service dealer, at a discounted price.
We use high-quality #2 ultra-low sulphur heating oil, loaded from local Long Island terminals, and delivered directly to your home. All heating oil in Suffolk County meets B5 requirements (5% biodiesel) as required by New York State.
Our COD oil quality is exactly the same or better than contract suppliers. The only difference is the business model—you’re not paying for automatic delivery services, equipment maintenance contracts, or administrative overhead that full-service companies build into their per-gallon pricing.
Local Resources
Useful Links
Other Services we provide in Middle Island
